Harris' takeover has been an an absolute success, but anyone claiming they knew it'd work out this way is lying or delusional. Just because we hit the low percentage chance that it all worked out doesn't mean people were wrong for thinking it was most likely a bad idea because all available history and information basically assured that it was.
That said, anyone that got vitriolic about it (on either side, tbf) can get bent. This is all uncharted waters right now. Being a dick about it either way isn't helping anything. Let's not pretend to know that anything is certain.
Yeah let's maybe hold off on the victory laps until after the election. This thing is on a knife's edge still and we got a lot of work to do still to get her over the line.
Still a knife edge, but there’s more space on this knife edge.
Though that debate performance. …. She was always going to eviscerate him… but she did it with style….
I knew that Harris would be a better candidate than Biden.
You’d have to be proverbially blind to not have seen it.
Did I know it would be this wildly successful? Not so much. I knew it could be, and I knew Harris would be better than Biden.
It wasn't even a sure thing that Harris would be the candidate to replace Biden.
I was going to bet a large amount of cash that Biden would lose. We hit rock bottom and all data proved Biden was at best at Jimmy Carter's level of performance with added baggage like age-related risk. I said then and say now that anyone would be better. Whether that was Harris or whether that was by an open convention -- which itself could've been exciting and similarly sucked away all attention from Trump -- either way.
At the end of the day all the data convinced not just me but countless Democratic representatives and eventually Biden's own campaign staff and advisors. Thank fuck he did the obviously right thing.
What I got wrong: I didn't believe Harris would work out this well, and in fact I was hoping for Whitmer among others if I'm honest... But I'm happily proven wrong.
I was also wrong about the VP pick. I wanted Kelly but Walz is the whole package.
This is what I don't get. Everyone here had the sentiment of "we will vote for anyone who is not Donald Trump". But then they balked at the suggestion that Biden should drop out and insisted that no one could replace him.
Now that Biden has been replaced.... they're saying Biden being replaced was a low percentage gamble. Something here doesn't add up.
because all available history and information basically assured that it was
That's actually just not true. It's pretty interesting, but the main reason incumbents have such a high chance of re-election is because exactly this happened with most incumbents that had a low chance already: They got cut out by the party. So there has always been natural cherry-picking that only the "good" incumbents went on to actually be the nominee again (and therefore had a disproportionally high rate of winning).
Although I originally also thought otherwise, when looking at all the data, this was the rational & correct choice.
While I appreciate data, nothing I see at a glance is very supportive of an incumbent potus dropping out being a good idea. I dont have much time to dig into it right now, but of the two incumbents they highlight in the article, both were VPs that assumed the office after an assassination, and in both elections, the incumbent party lost the white house. Neither are particularly similar to the situation in 2024, nor do they suggest that pulling the incumbent would be a good idea.
womp womp i knew it. something about having a cadaver up on stage just spoke to me…
The only reservation I had was that the democrats would pick a worse candidate. Because democrats always do that shit.
it all worked out
ARGH DON'T JINX IT
Harris' takeover has been an an absolute success, but anyone claiming they knew it'd work out this way is lying or delusional.
This is cope. It was obvious.
"Cope" lol. Take some time offline. You obviously need it.
It's so fucking gross seeing people act like this over something so serious. The same people would have been unbelievably indignant had they turned out to be wrong, like the absolute children that they are.
I was saying that before he dropped, I was wrong, you were right. Brilliant even. This has been not only the right move, but a huge shot in the arm for voter turnout and engagement. We would have lost this if everyone listened to me. I'll be more open minded going forward. Thank you.
thank you, it’s good to be heard and acknowledged for once :)
Reminder that anything that currently makes you feel happy and content in saving american democracy is likely a conservative psy-op designed to keep you home on voting day.
Remain scared citizen, remain frantic until after voting day. Feel free to relax afterwards.
You need people engaged and energized to show up to vote. Optimism is unfortunately a huge help in every case.
I was definitely in the camp of “Biden shouldn’t drop out” not because I wanted Biden to be President, but mostly because the people who wanted him to drop out just kinda hand waved away what happened after he dropped out.
They tossed about a few names that they favored and Harris wasn’t really on that list. People gave her a pass or offered some soft criticism, but she wasn’t on people’s short list.
While I’m very glad that Harris has really shone, I think that surprised a lot of people, there was still the opportunity for the DNC to fuck everything up and put together a ticket that would have been underwhelming. Luckily that didn’t happen.
I think this is an incredibly lucky “I told ya so”, the gamble worked out, but IMO it could have gone the other way far too easily.
wish i got this well thought out and measured of a response 4 months ago. instead it was me getting called. “russian bot” “useful idiot” “MAGA troll” 🤷♀️🤷♀️🤷♀️ me being “lucky” or not, did not justify that level of toxicity. thanks for this post tho
Yeah, this is the correct take here. Trying to pretend that this was the plan all along is disingenuous. There was no plan other than 'Biden bad'.
The fact that Kamala Harris has clutched momentum and has good odds came out of literally nowhere, as did Harris herself.
It also can't be ignored that the 'Biden bad' message was being pushed hard artificially by billionaires and Russia, which didn't exactly fill a lot of Democrats with hope that it was a realistic option.
We lucked out.
we did not luck out and the plan was not “biden bad.”
the plan was “biden is increasingly showing age and is actively losing an election that should be easy to win. polling shows that any other generic nominee does better than joseph robinette biden, so the logical next step is to replace him with his vice president.”
the trouble is we said that, and you didn’t listen. i was actively scoffed at and called a nazi for saying the above. poll data that showed proof of the above was downvoted and called manipulation. even when the donors started stepping down, it was still called fraudulent and irrelevant. i never hand waved someone asking me who replaces biden, and i always responded harris especially as the time got later. and again i was downvoted and scoffed at for that.
this was not luck, and you should start actively listening to people you disagree with more because you display some saddening signs of intentional ignorance here.
Thank you. I was in the same boat. Did I want Biden President again? Not really. But there were no alternatives at the time and I thought that Harris wasn't exactly getting the recognition when people wanted to just drop Biden.
I'm glad I'm wrong about staying with Biden. I'm happier that Harris has taken up the mantle. I just hope that it's enough to drive turnout.
Raise your hand if you were called a Russian bot for daring to question Biden
I guess the Russian bots are downvoting you.
I got so much shit on Lemmy for saying Biden should drop after his debate. Was literally called a Russian bot multiple times.
There's still plenty of time for you to become a Russian bot. Never give up on your dreams!
🙋♂️
my hand fucking shattered against the ceiling after reading this comment
I mean we should be questioning Trump's aptitude every chance we get for the same reasons they were doing it - it makes him look weak, it generates more discussion and therefore more doubt, and it drives down voter enthusiasm.
The reason nobody questions Trump is because there is no question. He is incompetent. Questioning it like questioning if the sky is blue. The only people who don't know he is incompetent are those who have lost all touch with reality. There is no swaying them because simple things like facts mean nothing to them so what is the point of continuing to shout the same things that every remotionally rational person already knows.
At least arguing about biden can lead to some actual change as we can see by the fact he isn't running anymore. We can't change the republicans but we can make the democrat party better so hopefully they can win.
Questioning him in public forums felt like it would’ve helped that very bad man. I’m glad the Joenors applied pressure - that’s very appropriate, e.g. donors calling out that garbage debate behind closed doors.
Russian bot is the new Godwin's Law. Nazis are common now and easy to spot. But even a leftist argument that's arguably suboptimal will be interpreted as a Russian bot.
Over and fucking over again.
Crust, that was pathetic low bar dismissal.
Well Russian bots were spreading the same rhetoric since they were trying to undermine Biden's campaign in order to get their Russian asset to win.
Just glad those bots helped the Democrats in the long run even if they didn't mean it. It has been a lot more quiet from those fronts since the change.
Right.... Because Trump definitely didn't want to go up against Biden so much that he begs for him back. Still gonna just excuse yourself by imagining it was bots cause it's easier than questioning your warped view of reality. I get it.
Not quiet cause the Democrats and left that wanted the change got it and therefore didn't need to keep raising the point against dismissal and denial... Sure.
yeah for sure the russian bots were pushing rhetoric that would replace literally the worst possible candidate to beat trump with someone better. that’s totally real and a strategy that was happening.
It's the equivalent of people walking by a bunch of Russians beating a politician in the street and jumping in to help them acting like you were doing it for a better candidate... That nobody know who one was... When nobody even ran against the candidate... The parting yourself on the back when some MUST step in them patting yourself on the back because we lucked the fuck out and Democratic Leadership actually nutted up including having the guy that got his ass beat basically give up because he was battered.
lol my favorite were those hiding behind Alan Lichtman... The guy who didn't predict a winner at the time yet and whose pre-prediction endorsement in 2016 was Hillary before later saying she'd lose lol.
You should see some of my submissions of focus groups post-debate insta-downvoted lol.
I'll take the L.
I legitimately thought there'd be no way for them to be able to campaign enough in just a few months and I'll gladly admit I was wrong.
sorry for the L, but i think we’re both glad you’re taking it :)
I’ve already apologized here, but I’ll do it again. I’m sorry. I was wrong. I didn’t think there was enough time to generate the support needed. I’m really impressed by Kamala’s campaign effectiveness.
accepted
Yeah, I admit, that was me. I think the rapid political cycle in news made me think the election was closer than it was.
thx for being a real one
I was wrong, and happy to be so now.
slay
I actually had someone go back to one of my comment chains explaining that we needed to push Biden to drop and apologize for their negativity and hostility towards the notion.
I think that is an absolute rarity of self awareness from anyone and I'll take the win of knowing there is at least 1 person out there that walked away with a change positive mindset.
....Wish it was more... But taking the win.
wait i love this actually
Yeah, I also was very vocal about this. The democrats that attacked this idea were fucking mean about it.
Absolutely grossly cruel about their disdain to anyone disagreeing and now just fully onboard without so much as a glance back at the wake of abuse left.
Honestly the Democrats can be exactly the same kind of bullies for like minded party thinking as the Republicans its just their shit apparently doesn't stink quite as much to have to take notice of it.
right like if you weren’t mean about it, no need to apologize. but there was so much shit being thrown around it was quite sad actually
My feeling right after the Biden-Trump debate was pretty much the same as my feeling after the Harris-Trump debate: I do not understand what the American electorate wants, and I can't predict their behavior. I was horrified by Biden's performance, but I couldn't say if that would matter. I was really pleased with Harris' performance, and I'm glad that it seems to be pushing things in the right direction, but by Odin's beard I cannot fathom how Trump could have a political career at all, let alone what it will take to really change the minds of anyone who is still undecided at this point. I'll take what I can get, but I can't predict the mental workings of undecided voters in Arizona, Georgia, or Wisconsin.
drop .... out? drop dead? drop trow? drop a new single?
DROP WHAT????
Drop that ass and let that booty shake. Let's go Joe!
Watch that booty bop when the bass drop
I'd listen to a Joe Biden single lol. Wonder if he'd try a dis track back at Bo Burnham lol
drop that tar pitch
Anyone who said Biden should drop was right as fuck. I was doubtful that it would work out for Kamala due to how racist people can be but it's going so well so far.
I was doubtful because it seemed like he wouldn’t drop out so intense opposition immediately after the primaries seemed like dooming us to 4 more years of trump. He did, it was a risky gamble and just because it worked out doesn’t mean I don’t stand by my thought processes and my absolute dread.
Oh yeah man. This shit is too risky.
Yeah, I was in the "Biden should drop, but I am gonna vote for him if he doesn't, because I don't have a better choice" camp.
I'm positive I didn't yell at you but we should listen to you more often is my take.
as we all know i am the only correct person on this site
Great way to split a party that just found renewed unity, get on my blocklist and stay there forever.
me learning i have the power to split an entire party by making a post on literally the most niche tiny and on-the-ground inactive community on the internet 🤯🤯🤯
I was wrong, and I'm sorry. Are we good now?
yeah have a good one :)
No, you haven't apologized for last Sunday. We know what you did.
No lol
childish and BORRINGGGG
I apologize. I was still, am still, very discomforted at the stakes riding on this election, and what it'll mean to future female candidates if both female nominations get trump presidential terms.
But I always look ahead with hope
<3
Pinging varyk
I hope we can at least agree this was a good move and we're in a much better position now to beat Trump
Jokes on you, everyone still hates me because I wanted a primary because I knew Harris would ignore my base requirement of preventing genocide.
Also because she's still pretty suboptimal compared to other candidates imo.
i agree with you on paragraph 1, ngl
2nd par depends on what metrics “optimal” describes, but generally, sure :)
This is equivalent to "well I didn't wear my seatbelt and I still lived.
Trends are trends.
what lol
You want an apology from having internet discussions relating to uncharted political waters? Why?
i dont want anything <3
They'll never admit it. In fact, they'll claim they knew it all along.
Nah I'll admit it, I was entirely wrong in thinking Biden should stay in the race. Though I could say I was worried another person than kamala would take their place I had essentially no faith in her ability at the time either.
Now look at where we are. Finally, some good fucking hopium. I'm very glad to be wrong
I’ll admit I was wrong. I thought any democratic candidate would be in a weaker spot if Biden withdrew, including Harris.
Harris did an excellent job of consolidating the party behind her, something I’m extremely grateful for.
Fuck that, I was wrong.
I believed the DNC would not change candidates, and as such, I firmly believed Biden should get the vote. I believed since Biden had indicated he would run, that he would be the candidate.
I'm happy Harris is in.
All that matters is trump doesn't win. Vote for Harris.
What I've argued a lot about here is third party, or staying home.
Depending on where you live, doing anything but voting for [democrat] (whoever it is) implicitly helps trump, due to basic game theory in an outcome constrained system.
In the future I'd love to talk election reform and building more progressive candidates, but that's not this election.
I've seen lots of people admitting they were wrong in the last month. At least some people seem to be trying to act in good faith.
I was wrong. I didn't think we had the time to find a good alternative, and I definitely didn't think Harris could be competitive. Happily eating crow! She and her campaign have been amazing!
You mean like all the ones admitting in this comment section?
imma give them the chance they never gave me
You accuse them of being childish while you are exactly as childish.
Nope.
