A lot of my friends weren't into the shift from Fallout 3's third person open world to the original game's isometric perspective; Understandable, but that's what I grew up on. I enjoy revisiting 1 & 2 every other year or so.
Also, Sid Meiers Pirates hadn't adapted well to modern systems, but has a clean gameplay loop that I enjoy revisiting.
I need to try that after I make my way through Planescape. I started BG1, but it just didn't jibe with me all that much, which apparently is true for a lot of people. I probably should've just jumped to BG2.
I ended up going back to the first one after I finished the second one. It has its charm, and a pretty good story. level cap and the difficulty is what makes it a bit hard.
I'm playing Bloodborne for the first time (emulator). Before that I was playing Far Cry 1 for the first time as well. Far cry was much harder, so far at least.
My favorite aspect was the B-movie feel to the whole thing. I was dying when my character got punted right in the face out of a flying helicopter. I wish I could find more games with some humor like that.