Yeah, y'all were doing it wrong. We always encourage picking creative answers. You need to be playing whatever the judge will pick, not what actually fits the best.
It's a pretty good introduction for those who don't care for swearing and sexual jokes. Better than Apples to Apples, I'd say. Could use room for improvement, I've been meaning to put together a combination of the full game and expansions that my whole family can play
I love how this company repeatedly rags on Hellmann's, but even more I love their Black Friday gags. But even more I love their political actions. I know it's all just marketing, but it's incredibly entertaining.
If you want a similar minded game but a different thematic an genre, try Munchkin.
It's a really good card game with goofy things like a weapon called Swiss Halberd (yes, it's like a Swiss knife but pole arms), or the monster "Amazon" which do not attack female characters, or the "Whine at the GM", which gets you a free level.
If you have a small group of friends to play with, it's a blast.
They each have their place imo, but I'd agree that A2A can definitely require more creativity and two people being on the same wavelength rather than CAH where the cards do almost all of the heavy lifting.
I assume this is a version of Apples To Apples that's just loaded with innuendo and double entendres? Because if so, that's hilarious and I need a copy.