Does multiple of Lemmy Community with the same name but on different instances matter or would it be mostly identical?
Does multiple of Lemmy Community with the same name but on different instances matter or would it be mostly identical?
I thought I might give Lemmy a tried as I want to not use Reddit as much and feel bad every time I do, even if it searching an problem I have and Reddit post is the top result.
Might be overthinking it but does community with same name but on different instances matter? I remember feeling little overwhelmed seeing few gaming communities but of course are on different instances and not sure if one is better or if joining them all is okay or just better to join in one. I wasn't sure if they would have different rule-set or how they deal with moderation as each would be a different moderation team I assume.
I have used Mastodon and Misskey forks for couple years but I hadn't use Lemmy as much and still a noob with it. Sorry if this has been asked loads of times, I just want an answer so I stop overthinking so much where I stop using it
It's the same thing as different subreddits with the same topic but slightly different names. Nothing special.
it does matter. they are technically managed by their local isntance, and do not share content. usually one will become 'popular' until the mods shit themselves, and everyone moves to a different instance. its one of the benefits of the 'verse
on some platforms, like my mbin instance links shared between communities are aggregated so you can view which one is getting the most activity
Just to add, some lemmy apps (eg. Thunder) also do a similar aggregation.
It's a pain in the butt. When people post, they often post to all of the communities, which fragments conversation - at least I think it does, since posts aren't shared across communities/instances.
But it's fine. If users are active, typically one community will be much larger than the others.
I don’t actually hate this phenomenon. In a way, it encourages more conversation because your individual comments are more likely to be seen and responded to by a human instead of having a few popular comments dominate the discussion. It also limits the reach of a power-tripping mod.
Communities need a critical mass of people to post/comment/like. Lemmy barely has that. Individual communities can almost get it. But if they're fragmented, they won't.
I changed how i look at communities when i switched to lemmy. Instead of just looking at the part before the @ i look at the whole thing and consider that to be its name.
So instead of the gaming community its [email protected] and [email protected] as a whole.
Tl;dr: theyre different separate comminities and the name is for all intents and purposes the entire thing.
I suggest subscribing to all of them for the topics you want and slowly through exposure learning which ones youd like to keep.
I wanted to add to others' comments: usernames as well.
So e.g. I could go create an account called [email protected], and another called [email protected], and another [email protected], etc. (assuming none of these already existed), and they each would be different - plus none of these would be you.
This is a reason why many celebrities say that they refuse to come to the Fediverse, b/c of this potential for misunderstanding regarding the account names - which tbf that is not entirely "new" issue since it would affect emails too, and yet in reality it is new b/c Twitter/X and Reddit and Facebook got people spoiled to expect a certain style of behavior so using the Fediverse feels to them a step backwards (we had a discussion about that topic recently).
So, exactly like email and a website URL, it takes the full thing to specify something exactly - a username, or a community.
They're separate. You can treat them as alternative subs.
When I read, I subscribe to all alternatives on a topic I care about - e.g. Android. Then browsing the Subscribed fees would show me posts from all of them.
When I post, I check their user/month count in order to decide which one to post to. If I'm posting something important, I'd cross post it to the others, just like people do to similar alternative subreddits.