No Stupid Questions @lemmy.world gylotip @lemmy.world 1y ago

Is Lemmy.ml instance blocked from Lemmy.world? And when will it federate again?

Posting to Lemmy.world from Lemmy.ml results in only Lemmy.ml users being able to see that post, so I think they blocked each other. When do you think they will be federated again?

22 comments

Lemmy.ml appears to be massively overloaded. Browsing their instance’s website results in network timeout errors. They haven’t applied the same fixes that lemmy.world has yet either. So, it’s not blocked, it’s just that lemmy.ml is currently unable to keep up with things.
You can see the list of blocked instances at /instances.

They are currently not blocked.
- But they are. Posting from Lemmy.ml results in only Lemmy.ml users being able to see it, so they are blocked.
  
  A fix for this was introduced in 0.18 and another one in 0.18.1. Version 0.18.1 is in release client 4 now, and lemmy.world just updated yesterday. Lemmy ml is still on 0.18.0 and doesn't have the 2nd fix yet. There are likely to be many causes to this, but consensus seems to be that federation has drastically improved since world upgraded to 0.18.1rc-4.
  
  So, what to do? Just be patient. These are growing pains and known issues being tracked by devs and admins across instances. If Lemmy.ml and Lemmy.world wanted to defederate, they would do exactly that, instead of some silly shadow-defederation as you're suggesting.
  
  If you want to follow the issue on GitHub, here is the link:
  
  https://github.com/LemmyNet/lemmy/issues/3101
  
  It could be federation buckling under the added weight of the new users from the sudden mass Reddit migration. The instances don't seem to be defederated, and those lists are public as said above.
  
  But federation failures from sudden increased load could explain it.
  
  Edit: federated -> defederated, darn autocorrect
  
  No, they aren't blocked. You can verify this for yourself by visiting https://lemmy.world/instances and searching for the text "lemmy.ml" (left column means they're connected, right column means they're blocked, not appearing means the lemmy.world server doesn't know that lemmy.ml exists)
  
  You can also visit https://lemmy.ml/instances and search for the text "lemmy.world" just to check the block isn't happening the other way around.
  
  I agree with others that what's happening is likely to be an issue caused by the vast number of new users that are joining Lemmy over the past few weeks (myself included!) - give it time, things will settle down. :)
Many federation things are broken atm. i know of Multiple communitys that are behind hours or Multiple days both on lemmy.world and Kbin the instance owner says their server got tons of recources free so its federation related bugs i guess.
Probably not blocked, but broken/overloaded...
maybe never, this is going to be a thing on and off with the large instances, get on a smaller one with a neutral rep and youll be able to interact with the whole fediverse as long as you don't cross lines.
- Exactly. Here's a great list to help people get started with choosing a different instance: https://github.com/maltfield/awesome-lemmy-instances
  
  ty, adding this to my resource guide
You can use this tool to check federation status in both directions: https://fba.ryona.agency/
- Thanks. Fyi. The search is case sensitive
I'll probably end up in a totally defederated instance or another platform altogether the way things are looking.
I just read this morning that someone is spamming the hell out of lemmy.world from what looks like an attempted DDoS run with a ton of communities with a bunch of random post with no actual content.
What's up with Lemmy.ml? Why would large instances block each other??? I'm genuinely confused
- They didn't block each other. It's just a server error.

22 comments