U.S. Senate passes defense bill that bars gender-affirming care for service members’ kids
U.S. Senate passes defense bill that bars gender-affirming care for service members’ kids
The U.S. Senate on Wednesday cleared a national defense authorization bill celebrated for troop pay raises but condemned by Democrats for targeting transgender children in military families, sending the bill to President Joe Biden’s desk.
Senators voted 83-12, with five not voting, to approve the $884.9 billion National Defense Authorization Act that received bipartisan praise for the pay bump, upgrades to military housing and investments in artificial intelligence and other advanced technology.
But the annual legislation drew ire this year from Democrats for a provision banning the military’s health program from covering certain treatments for youth experiencing gender dysphoria, defined by doctors as the mismatch between a person’s sex assigned at birth and the gender they experience in everyday life.
All Democrats present for the Dec. 11 U.S. House vote opposed the defense package, which passed along party lines under the Republican majority.
The White House has not released its position on the bill, as it generally does with legislation ready for the president’s signature.
We prevented like 10 teenagers from being able to talk to their doctors about their gender dysphoria. Really making America great again, guys /s
Why can't doctors just be allowed to do their jobs? And patients just be allowed to tell their doctors what is going on with them?
Tricare has around 2 million children on it. Around 1% of the population is trans, so that's 20k trans kids receiving healthcare under Tricare. Considering the untreated trans suicide rate is around 40%, if even a quarter of that succeed...
Well, I'm sure those 2,000 child corpses will be worth it in the end. What's a few thousand dead kids in the grand scheme of thing, eh?
These people are child murderers. They better hope there is no Hell, because if there is, they each assuredly secured their place there.
1% of the population is trans
I will not downplay trans rights, but I cannot believe 1 of 100 people are truly trans. That's a stunning number, over 330K Americans.
Let's do some simple thought experiments. How many trans people have you personally known? After 54 years in this world, I can't think of a single one. I've have had loads of gay acquaintances, friends, coworkers, etc. All I got on my mind was a trans woman at the Home Depot that really knew her shit about paint. Loved her, she's gone. Yes, being closeted will skew that number big time, I get that.
And I'm not talking about teenagers. FFS, given the current social environment I would have called myself trans at 17, always been in touch with my feminine side. Used to always joke that I should have been born a woman. LOL, I'm wearing a woman's blouse right now! (Skinny guys! Have a look at women's clothes! They're cut for us.) Yet on the Kinsey scale, I'm pegging hetero and masculine.
It's not even just preventing the teenagers from deciding on their own, even with fully supportive parents this prevents coverage. Government knows best from the party of "small government", and supported by the majority of the party nominally defending the victims. While that party still controls the senate!
*dysphoria
Fixed. Thank you!
The roll call for the vote (linked in the summary) is embarrassing for the senate Democrats. This is well beyond a few moderates dismissing the anti-trans measures as being unimportant and carried through to the core of the party and even some progressive senators. And it needed 60 votes to pass so it wasn't a foregone conclusion. The amendment to remove the provision didn't even receive a vote.
The Democrats who voted against:
- Baldwin (D-WI)
- Booker (D-NJ)
- Markey (D-MA)
- Merkley (D-OR)
- Sanders (I-VT)
- Schatz (D-HI)
- Schiff (D-CA)
- Stabenow (D-MI)
- Warren (D-MA)
- Wyden (D-OR)
The Democratic party is a right wing party
Both parties owned by the rich
Nice job, Washington state... aren't we supposed to be progressive or something? Patty Murray and Maria Cantwell are both corpo sellout nightmares.
I'm in Hawaii, usually Hirono is pretty reliable and Schatz is the "usually good but sometimes bad" camp. And Case is just reliably as bad as he can be without being fully mask off. I really wish someone would challenge him that isn't a "who the hell is that", but to be honest we don't have any good state-level politicians that would fit the bill.
Glad to see my Merkley and Wyden remaining based as always
Massachusetts and Oregon are the only states that can just be happy with good senate representation. I suppose Wisconsinites probably didn't expect their Republican senator to do anything good too, but that's a larger problem.
The roll call for the vote (linked in the summary) is embarrassing for the senate Democrats.
It would be if they weren't deliberately sending a message to trans people that they consider them expendable.
And the Democrats wonder why they keep losing elections
Clearly they need to move to the right even more, lecture harder, throw more vulnerable minorities under the bus, and get endorsements from even more Cheneys.
You expected them to tank the yearly National Defense Authorization Act?! I'm quite certain there's far more evil shit in this bill than denying care for transsexual kids.
Does anyone think any politician was zeroed in on this line item, among thousands?! It's a monster bill, maybe the biggest of the year. Pols put riders in there, always have, always will. This is a shitty rider, and there are thousands, every year.
Want change? Let's narrow the scope of bills to their intended purpose. Of course then our politicians don't get to wheel and deal, and that's what we're hoping they do, for us. No easy answer to this.
This is bullshit.
Yes,.fucking scuttle the damn bill.
"With Democrats like these, who needs Republicans"
Democrats like these need Republicans. If it weren't for Republicans, they wouldn't have anyone to be second worst to.
I've just about fucken had it with this.
We've moved from promoting troop suicide via ptsd (war, torture, and sexual violence) without support to also trying to get their kids to kill themselves first