Skip Navigation

Any other CEO would have been fired for what Elon Musk just said

edition.cnn.com /2024/10/23/business/elon-musk-nazi-jokes
Embed prevented alt text
25
25 comments
  • Elon Musk is not the CEO of the website formerly known as Twitter, he hired Linda Yaccarino as CEO in 2023. CNN is fucking stupid. Hes the private owner, you can't be fired from that.

    (Note: I am not an elon stan, fuck that guy. Just clearing up any misconceptions)

  • Here, I clicked the link so you don't have to.

  • On Monday, Elon Musk invoked the names of two German Nazis in a tweet while simultaneously disparaging modern pronoun conventions — attempting, as he so often does, to make a joke. (I’m not repeating the text here — not because it’s profane, but mostly because it’s just not funny.)

    🔥

  • https://archive.is/sF6Jk

    Archived version of the Spiegel 'hit piece'. Sadly, translate websites don't work with the archive site, so you'll have to use browser-integrated translation tools, like Firefox has nowadays. Though, I tested the translation of Firefox and it's rough in places. Certainly doesn't read as eloquently in English as it does in German.

    • Here's a better translation. It's long.


      Trump Crony Elon Musk: Public Enemy Number Two

      Elon Musk owns powerful companies, rockets, satellites, the X network. Now, together with Donald Trump, he's taking aim at his biggest project: the erosion of liberal democracy.

      By Markus Becker, Simon Book, Max Hoppenstedt and Marcel Rosenbach

      Perhaps one should simply listen more closely to Elon Musk. Recently, for example, in his interview with the far-right US talker Tucker Carlson: So far, no one has tried to kill the Democratic presidential candidate Kamala Harris, he said, "because it would have been pointless" - and called her a "puppet" and a "marionette". Amid much laughter. He had previously tweeted and deleted similar things. Because he realized that some of his fans might understand that as a call to action?

      Or his tirade against Taylor Swift, the most successful musician of our time, an avowed Democrat, smeared by the Trump camp as a "childless cat lady". A day after Swift publicly endorsed Kamala Harris, Musk wrote to his 200 million followers on X: "Nice Taylor ... you won ... I will give you a child and protect your cats with my life." Just a crude joke? Or a threat of rape? Misogynistic, in any case.

      A normal company boss probably wouldn't have survived any of these statements in office.

      Recently, Musk appeared alongside his new close friend Donald Trump, who returned to Butler, Pennsylvania a few days ago to let fans celebrate him at the site of his rally. With him on stage stood Musk, dressed in a "Dark MAGA" cap, Make America Great Again in black letters on a black background. In this getup, he spoke and painted the darkest pictures, serving the crowd a pile of hair-raising untruths:

      The Harris camp wants to steal the election, abolish democracy, silence them. The only one who can preserve the Constitution of the United States, save the nation, is Trump. "We must win. We must," Musk called out to Trump supporters. Otherwise, "this will be our last election here."

      Another boundary crossed, again without consequences.

      Probably one should not only listen more closely to Elon Musk. You actually have to. Anything else would be naive.

      In 2016 and 2020, the sharpest attacks on the US election came from the shadows: Russian troll factories tried to manipulate the public covertly. The Capitol stormers gathered online primarily in dark niches of the web.

      This time, the attacks are coming from one of the heart chambers of the country: Silicon Valley. And they can be observed on an open stage, read in feeds clicked millions of times by Musk and the online mob following him.

      The richest man in the world, equipped with a big mouth, a fortune of 250 billion dollars, a publicly celebrated penchant for intoxicants against his depression and illnesses, an astonishing love for autocrats and dictators, a now strictly right-wing worldview and a hatred for everything woke, leftist, queer or even just too democratic, embodies a completely new type of magnate: He not only controls access to the masses. But also to virtually inexhaustible sources of money. And, most importantly, to state-of-the-art high-tech infrastructure.

      For months, Musk has been supporting Trump's re-election with his own specially founded supporter association, called a PAC, pumped up with hundreds of millions of dollars. Time and again, the two met at Trump's Florida club Mar-a-Lago to broker the deal. In the past three months alone, Musk transferred a whopping 75 million to @America's account - to capture votes. The PAC promises a $47 cash bonus to all those who recruit a new Trump voter in the swing states who pledges to the PAC's goals. Musk himself has just set off on a multi-day roadshow through Pennsylvania to convince people there of world savior Trump.

      According to the mission statement, @America - and thus Musk - is about taking a hard line on immigration and having as little regulation as possible, for example on gun ownership. The multi-entrepreneur has been pursuing his crusade against any form of "wokeness" since his once son-born daughter Vivian Jenna Wilson publicly disowned him. He had been a cruel father who "desperately seeks attention and validation from an army of conspiracy-theorizing online users," she wrote on the web. Previously, Musk had declared her "dead" because of her decision to live as a woman - and as a victim of the "Woke mind virus".

      The billionaire's weapon of choice against this virus is his platform X, formerly Twitter. Here he not only incites hatred himself. He also uses X to specifically amplify the reach of Trump's lies - and delete unwanted criticism. Colloquially, this is called censorship. Yet Musk had allegedly once bought the former Twitter to secure humanity's right to free expression.

      Musk not only dominates the world of tweets. The power he can wield through his various companies is nothing short of dizzying.

      Since 2008, his automaker Tesla has put seven million electric cars on the roads - which Musk could control remotely if he wanted to. Without his space company SpaceX and its rockets, NASA today can hardly launch a single satellite into space. With Neuralink, Musk recently obtained regulatory approval in the U.S. to implant chips into human brains. Musk's satellite Internet provider Starlink brings broadband connections to the most remote corners of the earth - and to every modern battlefield. Including Ukraine and Israel. It's hard to imagine what would happen if he simply shut down the network there.

      An anti-democratic attitude paired with power over mobile, flying, digital, and high-tech infrastructure - typically, those are the ingredients for the villain's role in a James Bond movie. "The World Is Not Enough" would fit well. Unfortunately, this dystopia is not playing out in the cinema, but in reality.

      Elon Musk's companies left a request from DER SPIEGEL unanswered. But even so, one can grasp the historically new dimensions of power Musk has accumulated. Perhaps best by comparing him to other moguls whose influence is or was not exactly small either.

      Rupert Murdoch, for example, owns newspapers like the Wall Street Journal and TV channels like Fox News worldwide, the man and his titles are staunchly conservative, right-wing in case of doubt. But he himself has never publicly appeared as an opinion leader, nor did he ever aspire to political office. Musk, on the other hand, is the loudest voice on his own global platform. In the event of a Trump election victory, he wants to become part of the U.S. government. Trump has already promised him that.

      In the 1920s, former Krupp director Alfred Hugenberg bought himself a media empire to wield in the election campaign: "Make the right wing strong for me!" In 1933, Adolf Hitler appointed him Reich Minister of Economics. Today, the conservative is considered a stirrup holder for the dictator. Hugenberg, Hitler? Does this overestimate Musk's historical role?

      So far, he has always been underestimated. German car managers long had nothing but scorn and derision for Tesla - until they only saw Musk's taillights. Similar with SpaceX. The very idea of wanting to compete with the state-owned NASA seemed completely crazy to many. Not to mention his mission to colonize Mars and reuse rockets.

      In fact, SpaceX has long since overtaken NASA. Last weekend, the arms of the launch pad caught his Starship's rockets again, a crazy spectacle. The American space agency now regularly uses the Musk rocket to bring new crews to the space station.

      Pushing boundaries, destroying boundaries is something like Musk's entrepreneurial elixir of life. Boundaries of technical feasibility, boundaries of what is conceivable, boundaries of the planet. Musk embodies the figure of the Silicon Valley system disruptor like no other. The man has disrupted entire industries and overcome seemingly ironclad laws.

      Now he is applying this principle to politics - and has found his suitable partner in Donald Trump. The biographical development is bizarre. Musk once declared himself a "moderate". Within a few years, he has become not only a right-wing political hardliner, but also an avowed opponent of the liberal democratic USA. The troll-in-chief has mutated into a political agitator. One could say: Donald Trump is probably the greatest current threat to the free world. But his buddy Musk is at least public enemy number two.

      It would be both naive and dangerous not to take Musk seriously on this, his probably most enormous and most consequential mission. So far, the man has only had one experience: No one can stop him.

      • Chapter 1: Personal Radicalization

        Paige Holland-Thielen chooses a restaurant with a gluten-free menu, heads for a table in the garden, orders a sandwich. She recently moved here with her partner, to Rochester, Minnesota. Far away from California or Texas, far away from Elon Musk. The places where Musk's companies are located, says the woman with long, curly hair, are beautiful. But nothing would bring her back there.

        Holland-Thielen has been through an odyssey. For four and a half years, the engineer worked in a leadership position at Musk's space company SpaceX, accompanying rocket launches and satellite flights. When she started in Austin, Texas, in 2018, Holland-Thielen says, SpaceX was "a dream job." "I've always loved space. Now I had the chance to really make something happen, to shoot real rockets into space."

        At least since Robert Louis Stevenson's Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde, humanity has known how close genius and madness can sometimes be. And listening to Holland-Thielen, it was similar with Musk as in the novel, in which the evil, murderous alter ego of Dr. Jekyll gradually breaks through.

        Dr. Elon and Mr. Musk? "That Elon can be an asshole," Holland-Thielen says, she knew when she signed on with SpaceX. Only the extent and speed of his radicalization were unimaginable to her.

        Holland-Thielen sips her water, then reports on Musk's escalation, at first slow, then progressing ever faster. There's this scene from the early 2020s, for example. Holland-Thielen was a team leader, responsible for the organizational process of rocket launches at SpaceX, when she learned through a colleague that Musk was currently on the way to a customer in a private jet with his - male - team leaders. "Everyone was there. Except me. Even though everything converged with me," Holland says. An oversight? That's when she first realized how Elon ticked, Holland-Thielen says. But when she told her manager about it, suggesting complaining directly to Musk about his sexism, he advised against it: That would lead directly to dismissal. He and the team, however, could not afford to lose Holland-Thielen at the moment.

        Soon Holland-Thielen found out that it wasn't just happening to her. She and her colleagues had to put up with sexual harassment in the workplace several times. One higher-ranking employee, for example, once reacted to a graphic with a "sexual allusion to an erect penis," asking her, "How can we get it up, higher, highest?" Musk himself had spoken many times on X and in internal emails about his "wiener," his sausage - and wanted that to be understood as a joke in hindsight. That's also what it says in a letter to the board of directors and a lawsuit Holland-Thielen and other employees filed against Musk in 2022. Both are available to DER SPIEGEL. She and seven other SpaceX managers were fired as a result. Almost nothing is left of Musk's once-touted "No Asshole" and "Zero Tolerance" policy toward foul-mouthed, abusive bosses, the employees complain in the letter. SpaceX's "current systems" and "culture do not live up to the company's stated values." Musk, who considers the lawsuits unfounded, mocks people based on their gender, sexual orientation, age or religion. The billionaire treats and judges women according to their bra size, runs "his company in the dark Middle Ages" and offers "those who question the 'Animal House' environment that they can find another job if they don't like it."

        All of this, the employees conclude, leaves only one conclusion: "SpaceX must quickly and expressly distance itself from Elon's personal brand."

        In fact, SpaceX is farther from that than ever. As with Tesla, Musk has filled the company's supervisory bodies with friends and relatives, at least people loyal to him. No objection is to be expected. Musk, the largest shareholder himself, exercises three roles simultaneously: Chief Executive Officer, Chief Technical Officer, and Chairman of the Board.

        Equipped with such omnipotence, Musk has shed any shyness about using his company as a means of coercion. SpaceX is indispensable not only for NASA. With Starlink, Musk also has enormous blackmail potential - against democrats as well as despots.

        The company appears in almost every global crisis: Starlink is used by paramilitary forces in Sudan, to fight Houthi rebels in Yemen, or in a hospital in the Gaza Strip. When Russia invaded Ukraine two and a half years ago and destroyed communications infrastructure across the board, it was Musk who, in an allegedly generous act, quickly restored Internet access to Ukrainians: He had Starlink activated there and donated receiving antennas. And when Hurricane "Helene" recently hit the southern U.S. states, President Joe Biden had to call on Musk for help to provide 30 days of free Starlink use for the areas affected by the hurricane.

        The more chaotic and insecure conditions become in the world, the better for Musk. From this perspective, too, Donald Trump would be a blessing for him. Global Internet traffic via his satellites has tripled in the past year alone. Starlink now has three million customers in 99 countries. More than six and a half billion dollars, analysts estimate, Musk is likely to turn over with them per year. 7,000 of his satellites circle the Earth today in low orbits, accounting for about 60 percent of all active spacecraft. One could say: Musk has long dominated space as well.

        How far he goes with this arsenal was recently shown in Brazil. When a constitutional judge there dared to ban Musk's short message service X from the country because the platform was continuously spreading disinformation and thus endangering public order, Musk insulted and threatened the court and Brazil's president - and finally picked a bizarre fight over his Internet provider Starlink, which is essential for local farmers, for example, who often control their machines with the help of the service. In the end, Musk accepted the millions in fines to get X unlocked again. But that seems to have only reinforced him in his furor - as his enthusiasm for Brazil's former right-wing populist president Jair Bolsonaro shows.

        For Holland-Thielen, her former boss is now a "dangerous person." She says she can't understand how people can still work in his companies and drive his cars. "I never want to give Elon another dollar or get one from him," she says. "I'm very, very shocked by what he's become."

25 comments