Am I missing something ? Content discrepancy between apps
I apologize in advance if this is a Lemmy thing that I don't understand but I've been noticing some content differences while using the Lemmy apps. I usually brushed those off as performance or API issues but I can't with this one.
I've been closely following Thunder's development so I was excited to see the nightly community but upon arrival it shows no posts and 5 subscribers. Checking from other apps I can see that there are 2 posts and ten times as many subscribers.
So is it an actual Thunder bug or a weird Lemmy feature ? I thought instances weren't supposed to impact content ?
Don't forget to unpin the previous release and pin this one !
Loving it so far, I'll probably be back with more feedback after testing but so far the one change that's weirding me out a bit is the new collapse only collapsing the parent comment. For some long comments it was very handy to collapse them and have a one line preview. Maybe a compromise with a pixel height would could work ? I just had a comment with a screenshot bigger than my screen and was sad when I clicked on it and still had to scroll the full length.
New settings are great <3 Great work !
Connect for Lemmy which is on the app store, not sure if there is a 5th one that I instantly uninstalled or if that's it.
Submitted the issue to GitHub !
For the lighter read background thing, we should try to find something that would also work for posts if that feature is on the roadmap and the best example I have for that is relay.
Also, love the inbox card shapes you made, maybe it should be the shape of the post cards as well !
Thank you so much for your work !
Super glad to see the arrival of the inbox though it still need works. When I open the inbox it shows up empty even though I've had replies in the past. I have to tap twice the envelop icon in the top right to make those past replies appear. So I guess the state of the page is :
- Unread by default
- Tap the enveloppe and toggles unread so no changes
- Tap the envelopp and toggle read and now the old replies appear
Not a fan of that enveloppe icon in general I think it's confusing. I'd rather have the unread messages appear in the same place but with a different/lighter background to show their state. This is personal preference as opposed to the previous point though.
Also not sure if it's the app or a mistake, but your first link in this post opens a 404 in Thunder. Opening the link in an external browser (nice new feature btw) shows that it tries to open "...tag/v0.2.1%252B6" as opposed to "...tag/v0.2.1%2B6".
Same for me, even searching only allows you to chose from a dropdown with your instances only. So no good for me but a shame because it's a very good one !
Good point and probably worth posting about it in the sub or the GitHub issue page. Devs are quite reactive.
I did ! Very solid as well and probable a close second place, but :
- The UI and themes are not there yet for me
- Even though I'm connected it keeps asking me to log in to interract with stuff so not usable for me at the moment.
- Search is only on added instances ?
Anyway I'm keeping all the apps installed and will follow their developments, try to give feedback. We are very close to having good app options. API will switch off soon and we have to be ready if we want to get "normal" folks.
I've tried a few on the Android side and Thunder is best so far so that's the one I would give a go first if I were you!
Clearly the best android app so far !
Hi guys, incredible work so far ! I installed like 5 apps to compare them and Thunder is clearly the best and the one I'm keeping.
My two requests would be :
- A setting to change the default feed when we launch the app. That setting exists and works on the lemmy webui but is not respected and absent in the settings of Thunder.
- I know from GitHub that you have a "Mark post as read" in your roadmap but to that I would add a functionality that convinced me to make Relay my main app when I used Reddit : Hide read post. When opening your feed that button would automatically remove read post and you would get posts that you haven't seen before. No more scrolling through pages of posts that you've already seen. I will add this addition to the relevant issue opened on GitHub.
Anyway app is already the most usable and the one I'm keeping. Thanks for the hard work and I'll stay around to track the progress ! Much love to the devs and users.