If You Love Ted Lasso ... Don't Miss These Other Great Depictions of Positive Masculinity - The Peabody Awards
If You Love Ted Lasso ... Don't Miss These Other Great Depictions of Positive Masculinity - The Peabody Awards
Welcome to Peabody Finds, the weekly newsletter for the Peabody Awards, offering our recommendations for powerful and thought-provoking media you should consider engaging. The newsletter offers deeper dives into Peabody-recognized programming (and...
Men of a certain age Mr corman Shrinking
I particularly love Shrinking. Jason Segel and Harrison Ford make a great pair.
Who knew Jason Sudeikis had such dramatic chops? I honestly forgot it was even him most of the time.
Shrinking might be a good positive depiction of positive masculinity (I don't think it is, he's a toxic asshole who puts his stuff on everyone else) but I couldn't get over the fact that he's supposed to be a therapist. I'm a psychotherapist and Segal's wildly unethical behaviour, never mind the unethical behaviour of his workmates (who should have reported him) made me really dislike this show. I loved Ted Lasso and Shrinking is not on the same level.
There were similar issues with unethical therapists in Ted Lasso. While it's not done in the same way, there are still a few unethical therapist-patient interactions (spoiler left below). Since both shows are Apple TV, I was joking that this is just a theme for AppleTV shows.
It IS possible to have ethical therapist-patient scenes that are also interesting, so maybe it's just easier for most shows to play it up.
I think with Shrinking, the characters are not perfect role models, but they're actively trying to improve and get better. They also don't share a lot of the usual issues with male characters. Overall I agree with you though.
Spoiler Ted Lasso
How the former marriage counsellor starts dating Ted's ex-wife and eventually gets married to her. That's so unethical that I can't think of the other examples right now.
The fact that the situation you mention in the spoiler is acknowledged in the show to be problematic from both a professional and personal perspective is dealt with in the show, iirc. It’s something Ted needs to come to grips with, and is in no small part related to his internal troubles. It’s not played for laughs or character development, and to the extent that the therapist wasn’t reported or sanctioned it is unfortunate but realistic.
I agree completely about the therapists in Ted Lasso, but they weren't the main characters in the story, so it didn't bother me so much.
It's really the reason I never started the show because I don't feel comfortable with such a recurring theme of depicting therapists as unprofessional. Like I'm fine if they were portrayed as humans ans struggling to deal with difficulties and struggling to help their clients but this is just icky to me
The only realistic therapist portrayal that I've seen in a movie or TV show is Steve Carrell's in The Patient.
I've never seen it but I'll have to watch it now. Every movie or television therapist I've ever seen are terrible.
Interesting - I hadn't heard of Mr. Corman yet at all. I'll give it a watch :)