If I was DMing that game I wouldn't argue, but every other NPC they encountered would say "Wow tall guy! You must be good at picking apples!" until they decided they needed to do a reincarnation to get away from it.
"Oh brave adventurers, I'm so glad you're here! I have a special mission for one of your party. If you meet me in this warehouse I will be sure to reward you handsomely....."