U.S. could lose democracy status, says global watchdog
U.S. could lose democracy status, says global watchdog
You're viewing part of a thread.
...You might want to study some more history there bub
Sure mate. Hereditary successions were usually smooth. In elective monarchies, there were more power struggles. Do you have anything to add other than insults?
Not to mention that monarchies last way longer than democracies on average throughout history.
Is that so? I would assume democracies last a lot longer than 10 to 50 years? Considering that most of the world has democracies and they tend to be at least since WW2 that does not feel right.
Considering I don't know any democracy that laster longer than 200-300 years and there are a lot of monarchies that lasted for many hundreds or even thousands of years.
And how are the material conditions for the average working-class person in those monarchies?
How much autonomy did they have over their lives compared to the 200 or 300 years they would have lived under a democracy?
How much suffering happened under monarchy compared to democracy?
Because if all of you are measuring is how long the ruling class can subjugate the working class, then sure I'm monarchy is better.
It doesn't mean I want to live under one, but you go ahead.
And how are the material conditions for the average working-class person in those monarchies?
Looking at today's monarchies, the conditions are about the same as in today's democracies.
How much autonomy did they have over their lives compared to the 200 or 300 years they would have lived under a democracy?
The same?
How much suffering happened under monarchy compared to democracy?
The same average amount of suffering.
Because if all of you are measuring is how long the ruling class can subjugate the working class, then sure I’m monarchy is better.
It's obviously the most important parameter. If the govt system can't even sustain itself for long enough, then it's not even worth considering it.
It doesn’t mean I want to live under one
Thanks for sharing your opinion.
Oh so by monarchies you mean constitutional monarchies? Because the ones still in existence have only been around since the mid 1600s.
And functionally they're democracies anyway.
I mean like Saudi Arabia, Malaysia, etc. By monarchies I mean all monarchies, but since you're comparing the quality of life of today's democracies it only makes sense to compare it to today's monarchies.