Phoenix Rising 1 - 2 New Mexico United | October 7, 2023

Scorers: Moreno 52', Portillo 83', Formella 89'

PHX Yellows: Novo 53',Trejo 59', Arteaga 59', Stenberg 79', Fuenmayor 82'

NMU Yellows: Seymore 53', Swartz 66', Portillo 70', Moreno 74', Hamilton 90+5', Thomas 90+8'