Let’s say you have a loop route. In one direction it’s mostly gently, but consistently and perceptively, uphill with several big descents and in the other direction it’s mostly gently downhill with several big climbs. Which direction do you pick?
I tend to pick the generally downhill route. I’d rather get my climbs over quickly on steep hills than slog it out going slowly uphill over a long distance.
Easily the gentle downhill with big climbs. I prefer to get elevation gain out of the way quickly, and find steep downhills to be more of a negative than anything.
For me it really depends what I'm trying to feel/do that day. I have a couple routes like that, that I do in both directions. They both have different purposes to me.
I would try to alternate the direction if I find myself developing a preference for either one. I guess it's kind of an introspective approach, but if I start to get too comfortable I always switch it up to avoid stagnation. Forcing myself to run something I don't prefer AND forcing myself to appreciate it challenges me. I like that. I'm Buddhist though, and part of that is the journey of self-challenge and analysis that we undertake.
I would prefer the gentle downhill for sure.
I tend to think about it in terms of potential energy. Everytime I ascend I store some energy in the form of potential energy. If I descend gently, I can make use of that energy little by little. Every step feels lighter on the way down. If I have to take a steep descend I have to waist the stored energy. If I would use it, I would become too fast and hurt myself. I have to make sure I safely disperse the energy.
I do not have any preference for a steep vs a gentle climb, though. I have to put in the energy either way