A fight erupts in U.S. housing market as deteriorated affordability clashes with the 'lock-in effect'
A fight erupts in U.S. housing market as deteriorated affordability clashes with the 'lock-in effect'
Housing economists say neither force should be ignored.
Saw this in a news article: The monthly principal payments on a $1M note at 3% is equal to the monthly payments of a $500,000 note at 9%.
So a 6% jump in interest rate effectively halves your buying power. Of course people aren't going to sell their houses if they don't have to.
Edit: got my percentages 1 point off.
which is precisely what needs to happen to bring housing costs down.
3% mortgages vastly inflated home prices. the people who bought at the top of the market should be feeling the hurt just like they did in 2008.
2008 saw the unprecedented approval of loans, but also there were a LOT of adjustable or variable rate mortgages. So as rates increased sharply, people all of a sudden were deep under water. At least here they still have low rates. even if it is on a higher priced house, their payments won’t be getting worse.
But yes housing prices are out of control. People are starting to feel it, and it could very quickly go wrong for people. People even have crazy high loans on used cars. Going to be very interesting how it plays out.
The monthly principal payments on a $1M note at 3% is equal to the monthly payments of a $500,000 note at 8%.
Running the numbers through an online mortgage calculator, I'm not seeing it quite that bad. Though, there are more variables than just the interest rate which need to be considered. I'm using the calculator at:
https://www.bankrate.com/mortgages/mortgage-calculator/
for those who want to follow along.A $1,000,000 mortgage at 3% over 30 years, with no down payment has a Principal and Interest payment of $4,216
A $500,000 mortgage at 8% over 30 years with no down payment has a Principal and Interest payment of $3,668So, not equal. If we assume a 20% down payment for each loan, leaving all other variables unchanged, we get $3,372 and $2,935 respectively. If we assume a constant $100,000 down payment (10% of the $1M mortgage and 20% of the $500k mortgage), the numbers are $3,794 and $2,935 respectively (there was no change for the $500k loan).
Overall, the claim seems to be incorrect. That said, if you look at the $500k loan, with a 20% down payment and drop the interest rate from 8% to 3%, the monthly payment drops from $2,935 to $1,686 and the total cost of the loan drops from $1,056,687 to $607,202, a rather significant drop.
Using basic mathematics isn't allowed in housing market discussion.
the only acceptable position is that mortgage rates must be forever low, so housing values can continue to rise!
anything else is unacceptable!
housing values can never fall! it's not allowed!
I miscalculated at 9% which is $4,023. Which is within $200 of the value. Regardless though my statement still stands. 6 interest points yields almost a 50% cut in buying power. Any of the other levers can tweak it but the core of the premise remains the same.
In a clash of opposing forces, the U.S. housing market finds itself embroiled in a fierce battle. On one side, deteriorated affordability resulting from a spike in mortgage rates from 3% to over 6% in 2022, just after national home prices surged by more than 40% during the Pandemic Housing Boom, is exerting downward pressure on home prices. On the other side, the scarcity of existing inventory, exacerbated by the “lock-in effect,” as many homeowners are reluctant to sell and buy anew, fearing the tradeoff from a 2% or 3% mortgage rate to one in the 6% to 7% range, is exerting upward pressure on home prices.
I feel like there's also a "locked out" effect... As in I'm locked out of the housing market entirely now. It's insanely frustrating as I was just working on a promotion that would leave me comfortably affording the cheaper houses, then covid screwed everything... Now I'd be paycheck to paycheck in a dilapidated shithole in the worst parts of the worst towns around and the way housing seems to work, it's just infinite growth forever so it's never going back down....
This is going to have an interesting effect on the labor market. With people being ‘locked-in’ it will ultimately reduce worker mobility. Combine with the emphasis on ‘back to the office’, this will reduce the labor pool available to employers.
The good news is that new build costs are coming down and builders are starting to ramp up again.
History has shown the working middle class owning a home is good for the economy because of upward mobility. I think you have it spot on.
Settle down mate. This is all far too complex and there are all together too many words up in your shit.
It's far simpler to just blame AirBnB like we usually do.
History has shown the working middle class owning a home is good for the economy because of upward mobility.