Skip Navigation

The Supreme Court Had A Few Surprises This Year. That Doesn’t Make It Moderate.

fivethirtyeight.com The Supreme Court Had A Few Surprises This Year. That Doesn’t Make It Moderate.

The second full term under the most conservative Supreme Court in modern history concluded last week, with major rulings on affirmative action, President Biden’…

Just because the conservative block in the supreme court didn't deliver every victory the right wanted does mean the court was more moderate this term.

7
7 comments
  • I would never call them moderate, because they are not. Republicans and Trump gave us this horrible court. Remember to vote out republicans every election you can.

    • Don't forget to heap plenty of blame on McConnell.
      Trump largely just took (federalist society's) recomendations and ran with it.

      it was McConnell that blocked Obama from getting some of his nominations in. Which put us in this position int he first place.
      Trump was the GOP's useful idiot- and while he's geniunely an awful person who should never be confused with human beings... Much of Trump's actions weren't his idea.

    • Exactly. The article really shows this as well

  • Kavenaugh looking to position himself as the swing vote after Robert's retires. 🤮

  • Even the decisions that aren't horrible on their face generally contain language within the opinions that essentially tells conservatives how to do it "right" next time ("right" = get the results they want).

    In Moore v. Harper, yeah, they could've ended democracy as we know it and chose not to. But in the majority opinion, Roberts basically said, "The plaintiffs went too far in asking us to endorse ISL, but if they'd just asked us to rule whether the NC Supreme Court went too far in its reading of state law, we would've gone their way." He also went out of his way to cite a precedent that says states can assign their electoral votes by House district if their state constitution doesn't prohibit it. For states that went electorally blue in 2020 but have gerrymandered-for-Republicans congressional districts (AZ and GA at a minimum), this would take states where Biden won a majority of individual votes, and give most of their electoral votes to the Republicans instead.

    Roberts is playing the long game.

7 comments