Should we ban scat fetish?
Should we ban scat fetish?
As admins, we removed the scat communities, thinking that scat was covered by the NSFL. However, some people have opposing views on this matter. What do you think about it? If people want it allowed, then we can restore content.
https://strawpoll.com/wby5Ae7PXyA
Edit: My answer for friends in the comments; The main reason NSFL was banned is because we currently don't have the tools to separate porn from NSFL. I'm in favor of the ban because I think its the same way in scat. If we had enough tools right now, we wouldn't be ban the NSFL either. Although, I agree that voting for niche fetishes doesn't make sense.
Edit 2: Also I don't want to think about shit anymore. I'm out 😀 https://lemmynsfw.com/post/117500
You're viewing a single thread.
Just a user here, but I'd say a small subset of users in other instances are already asking to defederate from this instance for some of the basic communities that show up, like gonewild. I just don't see allowing a fetish "at this time" being helpful to the situation.
The mod tools are not there yet, even if you added the ability to opt-in on just this instance. If someone subscribes to the community from a different instance it will show up for ALL USERS on the all feed for that instance. And well, thats just shitty (pun intended) for those who don't like the kink but want to see nsfw communities. Now you've put the problem on the users who must choose to block the community.
So, while I'm a big supporter of kinks, I am not in support of allowing it on lemmy today. voted accordingly.
If someone subscribes to the community from a different instance it will show up for ALL USERS on the all feed for that instance.
Wow, that seems like something that needs to be changed ASAP.
That's a feature, not a bug, though there's some debate on the Lemmy GitHub about the wisdom of locally caching federated nsfw content.
It should be possible to cache the content without displaying it. Caching content should be a performance enhancement that doesn't otherwise impact users.
Caching has other downsides though, mostly for content that might not be legal in an instance's jurisdiction.
Seems like there should be an option under profile to include nsfw in the all feed, which would solve a lot of these complaints