I'm Conflicted
I'm Conflicted
I have a Pixel 4a (with Calyx) for a few years already (start of 2021) and it's still going great. The battery is okay. Everything works nice. It's smooth. It runs everything perfectly fine.
This makes me glad to see that hardware wise this phone was really built to last, I can't even count how many times I dropped it so hard that I was scared to see the damage (which was always either nothing or a broken screen protector)
But software wise I'm screwed as security updates are already gone from Google and I only get the extended support from Calyx which will also end soon.
Now I'm forced to choose between having a phone that is insecure or buying a new one.
So thanks Google for the high quality hardware, but what's up with this software planned obsolescence??
I know this isn't exactly right to repair, but it also kind of is because if Google decided to ditch the 4a, they should be forced to open source the software so that the public can actually repair it.
I'm sure that some of their latest updates can be modified slightly to work for the 4a, but they don't care and for them this is a win-win since they don't have to maintian support and they get new customers who would otherwise be satisfied with an "old" phone.
What happened to the days when an old phone meant a phone that was already crumbling to pieces, and not a fully functional computer that is slightly older then a toddler?
You're viewing a single thread.
when was the last time you heard of an older model smart phone model or line becoming so insecure due to the lack of ongoing "operating system" or "manufacturers security updates", off the top of my head I can't think of one
A whole lot if you take a look at last year's Android CVEs: https://www.cvedetails.com/vulnerability-list/vendor_id-1224/product_id-19997/Google-Android.html?page=1&cvssscoremin=7&year=2023&order=1&trc=1422&sha=2132554d4f7ce75c086fd81a1f91a6e6668d71cb
cheers for that, but all i see on that list is a whole bunch of "this could lead" and "there's a possibility", not any widespread outtages of breaches of entire product lines, like we have seen in the past with botnets and viruses in the pc world. i'm all for precaution, but again, i can't think of a time there's been a worldwide, or even nationally localized, smart phone infection across a brand or product line due to the ending of regular security updates, and i'd be interested if anyone knew if there ever has been.
what i'm thinking is, while it's best practice to have manufacturers/phone company os gui security updates for any smart phone in use, it's not the end of the world if there aren't. i could be wrong, but "this could lead" and "there's a possibility" is warning, not proof or anything at all
I'm sorry but you are wrong, if there is a CVE it means it works, and "could lead to" means that it literary can lead to that outcome.
All you need it one really bad CVE or a few bad-ish ones to do a lot of damage.
sure, could lead to, show where it has, in small groups, or large, ever, for any smart phone
Botnets targeting android devices are a thing, here's an example: https://blog.fox-it.com/2023/09/11/from-ermac-to-hook-investigating-the-technical-differences-between-two-android-malware-variants/
In this example, they're renting access for thousands of dollars. These people have a clear motivation to find ways to exploit devices and unpatched CVEs are an easy way for them to do that.
ok, i browsed through that, and again, am not seeing where it actually was deployed and affected end users, just a breakdown of how it could, and what i've continually been requesting, wondering about is if a botnet/virus campaign has ever been actually pushed out to smart phones, anywhere, at any time, due to the ending of manufacturers security updates, and again, i've yet to be presented with any evidence it has (only that it could be)
Look, when it comes to security statistics, a lot of it is locked behind closed doors in all kinds of big security companies. I can tell you personally that I have worked in such a company and you could see a lot of exploitation (attempts) on Android devices. It was there.
Look once there's a CVE and there is a POC for it. Usually there comes a Metasploit module for it and then it's for sure being used by a bunch of people.
aha, the old, i know it happened, i just can't produce any real proof of it happening, anywhere, to anyone, at any time. got it. well, shit, i'm convinced, guess you shouldn't use that Pixel 4a then. question answered, problem solved. be well.
Look, I have no interest in convincing you, you can also find some materials online but yeah, plenty of this info is closed source, that's just how it is with some industries.
If you want to throw caution to the wind because you couldn't find anything that is your choice.