You're viewing a single thread.
Letting people travel "how they want" he says while cancelling new train lines for those who wants to use that. The blokes a disengenuious wanker who we can't be rid of quick enough.
That's why railways should be privatised.
Typical conservative strategy:
- Public thing exists
- Become a lead weight in government so public thing gets underfunded and cannot adapt to market changes.
- Public thing no longer meets expectations.
- "See? It should be privatized and you won't have this issue"
- Privatize thing. A few people make a crap load of money in the transition. Thing starts out acceptable for the first few years.
- "Oh no, capitalism uses an infinite growth ponzi model. How do we increase shareholder value this year?"
- Private thing gets underfunded and consumers get manipulated and abused.
Are we winning yet?
Wut?
Absolutely fucking not. Privatisation is literally the worst thing you could do. Do we really want some random assholes to own something we rely on and try to squeeze it for as much profit as possible? I don't, fuck capitalism
Absolutely fucking yes! Nationalised railways never work.
Except they do and are
Except they don't.
Okay, prove it
Britain has nationalised railways since 1940-s and they've been in a desperate state ever since. The biggest railway nationalisation experiment turned out to be the biggest flop.
Privatized public transportation rarely works. At most you'll find some success stories of companies that partnered with a government to jointly service a transportation line.
No, it always works. Nationalised transport doesn't work though.
Thanks for providing these examples. They completely changed my mind about public transportation privatization
The example is across the channel - the whole of EU. And Japan as well. One must blind to think that nationalised transport can work.
In France, nationalized transport worked for decades before rail was opened to private compagnies circa 2014 (would have to check exactly). Since then, no one has been able to afford a train ticket. You have no idea what you're talking about
Japan literally has privatized roads and it's kind of a nightmare. You have to pay tolls for nearly all highway transportation because it's owned by 3 companies.
Yeah, privatization is great...
Didn't England already go through that, and wasn't it a complete failure ? someone knowledgeable quick please
Relevant video: https://youtu.be/DlTq8DbRs4k?si=y-muiI81MKk3gin0
Privatized railways are mostly failures most of the time. Besides Brightline, and I think a bunch of the Japanese railway companies, no nation really has privatized passenger rail. But I think the Japanese system has a weird setup.
Actually, I think Italy and Germany have started allowing private companies to operate on their railways, but I think they need to fit it between the nationalized services. I could be wrong about that tho.
Not really. British railways are 100% nationalised. All privatisation efforts have failed.
So, yes ?
I disagree. Aside from privately owned Brightline who already owns the land around their stations, owns their tracks, and has a lot of incentive to expand their coverage, I have not heard of a single other piece of privatized infrastructure that actually benefits the users or actively engages in expansion
