What are your thoughts on Beehaw defederating?
What are your thoughts on Beehaw defederating?
hey folks, we’ll be quick and to the point with this one: ##### we have made the decision to defederate from lemmy.world and sh.itjust.works. we recognize this is hugely inconvenient for a wide variety of reasons, but we think this is a decision we need to take immediately. the remainder of the post...
My first account on the fediverse was on Beehaw and I was happy with it, but defederating from two of the largest instances gave me a reason to find a new instance. Personally I understand and respect the decision -that is the point of the fediverse afterall.
They had a lot of good communities that will not be cut off from the fastest growing instances which will make things tough to rebuild I think.
You're viewing a single thread.
I'm terribly sorry to be a noob about these matters but what is "defederating from another instance" mean? Communities from those instances won't be cached at beehaw?
It means that we cannot see posts and communities from beehaw and vice versa. They basically made themselfs an island. Which is fine, that's the power of Lemmy, we can just move somewhere else if we dont want that. Or join them if you like the small community feeling.
So users from those 2 instances can't participate at all communities hosted on beehaw?
If that is so, I think it's good because it incentivizes
- Stricter checks while signups
- Making sure communities are more spread out over several instances
- Behave well or get out
- Not becoming 4chan
Making sure communities are more spread out over several instances
that is not good thing. the more people, the bigger the chance you get answer to your question or information that interests you, spreading them out is counterproductive to the goal of discussion forum.
This is true, but I think @[email protected]'s concerns are also true. I think the biggest thing here is us all learning how to navigate the tech and getting better and more refined tools where needed.
Not to sound condescending, but the reason why I signed up here instead of beehaw is because I read their mission statement. I said, "Cool, I 100% agree with this, but I'd personally rather not be so restricted." I didn't exactly see this coming, but reading it again it's no surprise.
The problem is that users on Beehaw also now can't participate in communities hosted on those two instances. So for a lot of people, half their subscription feed is now dead with no warning. Unfortunately the defederation options at the moment are a bit "all or nothing".