Visit our fresh communities on Lemdro.id! Please check sidebar before posting!

Communities

Join a few of our fresh communities! Please don't mind the dust as we work on getting settled.

Recommend a Community

Is there a technology-related community you would like to see on Lemdro.id? Share a comment below with your suggestions!

Seeking Experienced Mods

Are you an experienced mod with an interest in supporting one of these communities or bringing over an existing community from Reddit? just reach out to @[email protected] to chat!

A Fediverse home for developers

Are you a Lemmy app developer looking for a home community on the Fediverse? We can help with that! Just send us a link to your Github or Play Store product page. We would be happy to host a community for you, including moderation support! No cost, of course. Just reach out to: @[email protected].

108

You're viewing a single thread.

108 comments

Hello everyone, why the mods are removing genuine posts? I know they break some rules you have. TBH there are too many rules, and this is very early stages of lemmy so don't be so strict. You guys are doing a too good job in my opinion.
- These are the same mods from the Android subreddit. That should answer everything you need to know.
  
  I understand why they are strict on Reddit. The sub is huge, but here, they are imo too strict considering how small the platform is.
  
  I'd give you a genuine answer, but I'm afraid these mods will ban me like they banned me from Reddit for having a negative opinion about Samsung.
  
  I'm so glad we gave these mods power of the Android community on Lemmy. Way to go, us!
  
  The cool thing about this platform is that we can just leave. There's another android community at [email protected]
  
  I can't believe [email protected] shut down
  
  It was shut down by the mods running the android community here.
  
  [email protected] is reopening on 7/24 though
  
  I can't believe [email protected] shut down
  
  there's also [email protected] and [email protected]
  
  I can't believe [email protected] shut down
  
  I can't believe [email protected] shut down
  
  The cooler thing is that [email protected] will be opened in a week or so with new mods. So we can just wait.
  
  I can't believe [email protected] shut down
  
  Honestly, I’m okay with them banning people for being negative, there are SO many places you can go to do that if you want to, especially with all the servers here on Lemmy.
  
  You think it's okay to ban someone for being critical about a specific Samsung device because a mod is a fanboy of it?
  
  You can be critical without being negative.
  
  I've looked into it and can confirm /u/JshKlsn was temporarily banned for rude comments directed at others on /r/android. For the record, the mod who actioned it does not use Samsung devices.
  
  It would be great if you could not talk behind my back with other users, but also your investigation means nothing, because who said that username was mine on Reddit, or that I am talking about that account?
  
  I'm not, for the record.
  
  Nothing private intended in this public thread. I did reply to you directly above but hadn't heard back.
  
  Happy to look into the account you're referring to, but I don't think JshKlsn is too common of a handle?
  
  Oh I'd love to see exactly how you got banned. Chances are it was for a tad more than just "having a negative opinion about Samsung".
  
  Same, got banned for "spam", even though I am pretty sure I never broke any rules.
  
  I asked for more reasons then, but they straight up ignore and mute me for 28 days.
  
  I will never subscribe to anything related to the old reddit mods.
  
  I am glad I am not the only one thinking this way.
  
  Hey there, if you would like to pass me your username on Reddit I'd be happy to take a look for you. We have folks who very much dislike Samsung so that shouldn't have been an issue - and if it was, it was an oversight.
  
  My user name on reddit is ST3RB3N666, can you tell me why you permently banned me? I tried to reach you, but you completely ignore me.
  
  I don't care about your ban, but at least tell me why did you ban me?
  
  EDIT: as expected, no response.
  
  Strange. I only received a notification for this reply when you edited it just now. Not sure if it's due to the recent lemmy.world outage. I'm on my way to the office at the moment but will definitely take a look this afternoon.
  
  Edit: I've taken a look. It appears you were banned for spam.
  
  You commented "Thank, I will definitely think about it in the future" as the first response to a spam bot post advertising third-party MagSafe accessories. This was your first comment on /r/Android.
  
  Your follow-up message to modmail followed the same format as typical spam accounts and was archived.
  
  13 days ago, you randomly sent a mod mail, "fuck you", which triggered automatic Reddit filtering.
  
  Of course, after 3 months of no response you deserve "fu#k you".
  
  So you banned me, because I was honestly interested in an accessory, gotcha.
  
  Spam? I didn't read the content policy, but I doubt I violated any rules with only one comment, can you kindly elaborate?
  
  This was my PM to you after you banned me. Does it look like a bot? It was just a formal way to communicate, since you are a moderator.
  
  Can ask why did you ban me? Spam? Can at least explain or you don't care? What ever am out
  
  Those are my follow up messages, where you muted me for 28 days right after.
  
  I m sorry for the "fu#k you", but you honestly deserved it, since you could take 5 minutes to explain yourself, but you decided to ignore me instead.
  
  I was gonna leave the platform anyway, so I decided to flip you off as last act as rebellion 🤣
  
  Have a great day and good luck with the instance. 🤙
  
  So nothing to do with you "having an opinion about Samsung", that was clear bullshit. How about you edit that comment and stop spreading bullshit?
  
  I didn't say it was for "having an opinion about Samsung" (it was another user), but to be honest, banning me because they believe I was a bot? Come-on, they could just look at my profile and see all my comments to discover that I was an actual human.
  
  I guess I was at wrong place and time, and got banned.
  
  See ya.
- I think they just removed my post. I don't think it broke any rules?
  
  Hi there, I hope you were able to catch some of the other comments but memes are captured under rule #3:
  
  Describe images/videos: Please provide an explanation in the self-post body when sharing images or videos. Memes are not allowed.
  
  Sorry for the late reply, I was away for much of the weekend until yesterday and thought we had gotten a reply out to you. Based on this discussion, we created [email protected] as a compromise between folks who want memes and those who do not. We've been aiming to find a balance between being more lenient during this period while also remaining responsive to user reports, which we did receive for yours.
  
  You can typically find an explanation of the removal reasons in the modlog (when accessed from the community sidebar). Unfortunately, Lemmy doesn't seem to be handling user notifications too well but hopefully this improves in the near future.
  
  Edit: Apologies for the multiple posts. App went haywire on me... Lemmy growing pains!
  
  This is exactly the kind of shit I was worried about when people were talking about attracting reddit mods to Lemmy.
  
  Good thing we can create or go to an alternative Android community. Any good ones ATM?
  
  There is [email protected] and [email protected] that I'm already subscribed to.
  
  I feel bad for you. Deleting a post which has already has a around 250 points, and around 60 comments SMH. Either delete them early or write a comment warning.
  
  My points keep getting reset every couple of days, so I don't care too much about that. I think I was making a valid point though. Obviously people were pretty engaged with it.
  
  Cool thing about lemmy is if these mods want to be jerks, I'll just go to another android community on another instance.
- Thanks for this feedback! Based on this discussion, we've created [email protected] as a compromise between folks who want memes and those who do not. Hope that helps! We've definitely been aiming to be a bit more lenient as things take shape while trying to also be responsive to user reporting.
  
  Always happy to check in again for a pulse check. Hopefully Lemmy can implement a better way to let directly notify folks when a post is removed, but in the meantime everyone can access the modlog from the community sidebar. Please let me know if not!

108 comments